I have really enjoyed Erika's previous article and am thrilled to bring you another one. The question of cardio is one that I often get and so in this article, Erika answers our questions about cardio exercise and PCOS.
Many of you contacted me after reading my article on “Belly Fat and PCOS.” I’m very excited and encouraged by all of your questions and comments! It’s been amazing to discover that so many women with PCOS are exercising!
Some of the women who reached out to me were fitness newbies while others spent more time at the gym than me! Regardless of experience level, it seemed that many women are under the impression that cardio exercise is the best way to burn calories and, more specifically, the more cardio you do, the more weight you will lose.
Aerobic exercise is one of several tools you have at your disposal when trying to lose weight. Unfortunately, many women who are dedicated to their fitness unknowingly sabotage their progress by misusing cardio. The treadmill is not a magic wrecking ball you can use to knock out that extra glass (or three) of wine or the slice of cake you had on Friday night.
It is 100% true that exercise burns calories and that if you exercise enough, you will burn enough calories to lose weight. However, this concept of weight control is flawed! Overeating is easy to do and can be done in mere minutes. Burning off an over-indulgent diet is difficult and takes hours of physical activity everyday!
I’ve found that when women get stuck in this line of thinking they often develop an unhealthy relationship with food and exercise.
I want you to avoid this pitfall! You should love both food and exercise! Nothing will have a more powerful influence over your health than what you eat and how often you move.
Start thinking of aerobic exercise as the shovel you use to dig a strong foundation for good health and a fit body. The objective of any exercise program is to stimulate physiological changes in the body that will enhance your health. The goal of your exercise program should never be to “burn off” the bad nutrition choices you’ve made!
The Two Types of Cardio Exercise
There are two types of cardio that I recommend including in your workout programs: high intensity interval training (HIIT) and steady-state moderate intensity cardio.
HIIT workouts use intervals to elicit a high intensity level from the exerciser. The trainee will alternate between bouts of extremely difficult fast-paced exercise and bouts of very low intensity work. For example, you might alternate between sprinting up a steep hill and walking on a flat surface.
Steady-state cardio is what most women think of when they hear the words ‘cardio workout.’ Steady-state workouts involve performing a repetitive movement at a steady, moderate pace for a sustained period of time. The most common examples of this are jogging or using an elliptical trainer for 40-90 minutes.
HIIT is especially important for women with PCOS because of the physiological effect it has on insulin sensitivity. Several medical studies have found that HIIT workouts are more effective than other forms of exercise at increasing insulin sensitivity.
A study published in the International Journal of Obesity compared young women who did HIIT workouts with young women who did steady-sate cardio workouts. The women who did HIIT had a 31% decrease in fasting insulin concentrations compared to 9% for the steady state group. The HIIT exercisers also lost, on average, 11.2% of their fat mass while the steady state group did not lose any fat.
Plus, there are an abundance of medical studies which prove that HIIT is the most time effective aerobic exercise for fat burning and stimulates more muscle growth then steady-state cardio.
In the face of all of this research, some may wonder if you should just skip steady-state cardio in favor of HIIT. Many fitness experts have taken this approach, but I feel it’s not the best choice for PCOS women.
Steady-state cardio has plenty of physiological benefits. In my opinion, the most important of these is that moderate to low intensity cardio is restorative.
I don’t think I am alone when I say that having PCOS is stressful. Whether you’re TTC or just trying to be healthy, PCOS can certainly bring on anxiety. Steady-state cardio, especially when it is done outdoors has been shown to ease psychological stress. In fact, some mental health professionals prescribe outdoor cardio as a treatment for anxiety and depression.
In addition to helping you renew your mind, moderate intensity aerobic exercise also helps your body recover from stress. Steady-state cardio stimulates your parasympathetic nervous system which is the division of your nervous system that shuts down your “fight or flight” responses to stress and allows you to rest and recover.
Moderate and low intensity exercise will help you recover from high intensity workouts. Moderate intensity aerobic workouts help increase blood flow to damaged muscle tissues and boost your recovery. Taking a day off from any physical activity is really not necessary for recovery especially since most of us spend our days seated at a desk and our evenings sitting on a couch. A moderate intensity cardio workout, like a brisk walk, is often the better choice.
A Balanced Cardio Workout Schedule
My suggestion to women with PCOS is to reap the benefits of both types of cardio. If you want to stay lean and healthy, you can’t go wrong with using a combination of HIIT workouts and moderate intensity cardio workouts.
I recommend doing one or two 20-30 minute HIIT workouts each week. You’ll have to decide what’s best for you based off how often you strength train and how quickly you recover from intense exercise. Be sure to warm-up properly and wait at least 24 hours before doing another high intensity workout like HIIT or strength training.
Here are links to a few of my favorite HIIT style workouts:
Once or twice a week, spend 30-45 minutes doing a moderate intensity cardio workout. Do not do any vigorous exercise on this day. The idea is to give your body a break and promote recovery, not to challenge yourself. You should be able to carry on a light conversation during this workout.
No matter what type of exercise you are doing, please remember that it is a tool you are using to enhance the quality of your life. Challenge yourself and allow yourself to recover, but never punish yourself or push yourself too far!
Love exercise, love food and love yourself!
Thanks, Erika! We would love to hear your thoughts and comments about how exercise has helped your PCOS. Also, what is your best form of exercise. Leave us a comment and let us know!
The Just Start Workout
Erika has just launched her new program, "The Just Start Workout", designed specifically for women with PCOS. We all know that exercise is crucial to managing our PCOS symptoms but we struggle with finding the time, motivation or even knowing what kinds of exercise to do. Erika's program will get you started with just 15 minutes a day. It' really manageable and won't cost you the earth. This may just be the missing piece for your PCOS management plan.
If you've been following this blog for a while, you'll know that I only recommend things that I firmly believe in and use myself. Erika has kindly offered all PCOS Diet Support readers a 20% discount. So, make sure you use coupon code "pcos20" for your discount.
Just so that you know, I am an affiliate for Erika's products and will make a small commission (hopefully enough to cover my weekly coffee 🙂 ). There are so many other products for women with PCOS that cost WAY more than Erika's exercise program and that I could make a lot more money from. But, I don't believe many of them work for PCOS and will only promote products on this site that I genuinely find useful and have personally gotten to know.